1. Texture and Blendability
Look for a formula that glides smoothly onto the eyelids without tugging or feeling sticky. The best cream eyeshadows blend seamlessly with fingers or brushes, allowing you to build color intensity with ease.
Free shipping and returns for BlueRewards members Sign Up
Free samples with all orders
FREE GIFTS WITH PURCHASE BROWSE NOW
Trish McEvoy
Hourglass
Laura Mercier
Charlotte Tilbury
Tom Ford
Surratt
Surratt
RMS Beauty
RMS Beauty
Cream eyeshadows offer effortless application and a modern, luminous finish—here’s what to consider when shopping for the perfect one.
1. Texture and Blendability
2. Longevity and Crease Resistance
3. Shade Range and Finish
4. Ingredients and Sensitivity
Looking to add a pop of color and shimmer to your eyelids? Our curated selection of cream eyeshadows offers a blendable, long-lasting alternative to traditional powder formulas. Whether you prefer a subtle wash of color or a bold, metallic finish, our top-rated cream eyeshadows have been handpicked based on user reviews. Discover the best cream eyeshadows that have garnered rave reviews for their pigmentation, texture, and staying power. Elevate your eye makeup game with these highly recommended cream eyeshadows that are sure to become staples in your beauty routine.
If you're not already a member, sign up
If you are a member, sign in