1. Pigmentation
Highly pigmented eye shadows deliver vibrant color payoff with less product. Look for formulas that provide rich, true-to-pan shades for striking results.
Up to 30% Off Almost Everything
Free shipping and returns for BlueRewards members Sign Up
FREE GIFTS WITH PURCHASE BROWSE NOW
Lune+Aster
Trish McEvoy
Trish McEvoy
Chantecaille
Chantecaille
Surratt
Dark Matter
Victoria Beckham Beauty
EyeWear
Chantecaille
Lune+Aster
Charlotte Tilbury
Choosing the best eye shadow can elevate your makeup look and enhance your eyes—here’s what to keep in mind.
1. Pigmentation
2. Blendability
3. Longevity
4. Finish and Shade Range
Elevate your eye makeup game with the best eye shadows as rated by our savvy community of beauty enthusiasts. Whether you're a fan of shimmering metallics, velvety mattes, or bold pops of color, our curated list showcases top-rated eye shadows that deliver on pigment, blendability, and lasting power. From everyday neutrals to statement-making hues, these coveted picks are sure to inspire endless creativity and confidence in your makeup looks. Dive into our user-reviewed selection and discover the perfect eye shadow to enhance your unique style and make your eyes pop like never before.
If you're not already a member, sign up
If you are a member, sign in