What to Look for in a Pencil Eyeliner

Choosing the right pencil eyeliner can enhance your eye look and ensure long-lasting wear.

1. Formula & Texture

Citrus catapult arrow

Look for a pencil eyeliner with a smooth, creamy formula that glides on easily without tugging at the delicate skin around your eyes. The ideal texture should be blendable for smudging, yet firm enough to create precise lines.

2. Longevity & Smudge-Resistance

Citrus catapult arrow

Consider eyeliners labeled as long-wearing, waterproof, or smudge-proof if you need all-day performance. These formulas help prevent fading, smudging, or transferring throughout the day.

3. Shade Range

Citrus catapult arrow

Choose from classic blacks and browns for everyday wear or explore bold colors to make your eyes pop. A wide shade selection allows you to customize your look for different occasions.

4. Ingredients & Sensitivity

Citrus catapult arrow

If you have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses, opt for ophthalmologist-tested and hypoallergenic formulas. Avoid harsh chemicals or fragrances that could cause irritation.

  1. 1

    Victoria Beckham Beauty

    30 REVIEWS
    BestSeller
    A creamy, smudge-free eyeliner with vivid, high-performance colors that simply demand attention.
  2. 2

    Neen

    5 REVIEWS
    A high-pigment pencil that doesn’t tug and just glides on.
  3. 3

    RevitaLash

    1 REVIEWS
    A richly pigmented, easy-to-use, cream eyeliner formula for high-impact, stay-true color.
  4. 4
    57 REVIEWS
    An automatic, retractable eye pencil with an integrated pencil sharpener.
  5. 5
    94 REVIEWS
    BestSeller
    An automatic, retractable eye pencil with an integrated pencil sharpener.
  6. 6
    18 REVIEWS
    Eye pencil with a firm and ultra-smooth tip that leaves a perfectly accurate line.
  7. 7

    Chantecaille

    10 REVIEWS
    For wide-awake eyes
  8. 8
    42 REVIEWS
    A dual-ended creamy pencil that packs intense color impact: rich, pigmented shades glide on velvety smooth and blend easily.
  9. 9

    Charlotte Tilbury

    344 REVIEWS
    A creamy, matte, high-pigment eyeliner in the iconic Pillow Talk smokey berry-brown shade.
  10. 10
    511 REVIEWS
    A classic kohl eye pencil that lines eyes with rich, creamy color in just one swipe. 

What to Look for in a Pencil Eyeliner

Choosing the right pencil eyeliner can enhance your eye look and ensure long-lasting wear.

1. Formula & Texture

Citrus catapult arrow

Look for a pencil eyeliner with a smooth, creamy formula that glides on easily without tugging at the delicate skin around your eyes. The ideal texture should be blendable for smudging, yet firm enough to create precise lines.

2. Longevity & Smudge-Resistance

Citrus catapult arrow

Consider eyeliners labeled as long-wearing, waterproof, or smudge-proof if you need all-day performance. These formulas help prevent fading, smudging, or transferring throughout the day.

3. Shade Range

Citrus catapult arrow

Choose from classic blacks and browns for everyday wear or explore bold colors to make your eyes pop. A wide shade selection allows you to customize your look for different occasions.

4. Ingredients & Sensitivity

Citrus catapult arrow

If you have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses, opt for ophthalmologist-tested and hypoallergenic formulas. Avoid harsh chemicals or fragrances that could cause irritation.